Cincinnati Mohawks
League: American Hockey League
Years: 1949-1952

Cincinnati Mohawks
League: International Hockey League
Years: 1952-1958

Cincinnati Wings *
League: Central Professional Hockey League
Years: 1963-1964

_{*The Indianapolis Capitols (parent club was the Detrit Red Wings) played 28 games at the Gardens as the Wings after the Indiana Fairgrounds Coliseum exploded and caught fire, killing 74 people and injuring more than 300.}

Cincinnati Swords
League: American Hockey League
Years: 1971-1974

Cincinnati Cyclones
League: East Coast Hockey League
Years: 1990-1992

Cincinnati Cyclones
League: International Hockey League
Years: 1992-1997

Cincinnati Mighty Ducks
League: American Hockey League
Years: 1997-2005